Can Iran’s Hossein Mousavi Be Like Harry Truman?

Harry Truman as a young man was bookish (I think that a good thing), was not a brawler (if I recall correctly from David McCullough’s book “Truman” had never even been in a fist-fight which is another plus), and wore thick glasses.  So when Truman was thrown into the mud and blood  in France during WW I, (at one point having lost his glasses) he was the first to admit his surprise at having the qualities of a leader.  But there he was in the horror of war leading men, and becoming a part of history.

As I was reading about the affairs of Iran this afternoon, and the future potential actions of Hossein Mousavi, the man who most claim to have won the Iranian election last week, I thought about Harry Truman.  Might Mousavi be more than what he campaigned as during the recent election?  And might that make him, like Truman, bigger than what he had once thought of himself?

Let me briefly explain.

Everything changed once the clerics in Iran defied the will of the young voters in Iran.  It is important to know that 3/4ths of the electorate is young, and as we have witnessed eager for change.  While there is a real possibility of massive bloodshed in an attempt to clamp down on the protesters, there is also a chance that the forces of change prevail, and Mousavi has the chance to lead.

At that point a huge demarcation line in Iran will have been crossed.  Mousavi, prior to the election, was seen as someone that would be more western-friendly, but still a product steeped in the ‘holiness’ of the Islamic Republic. 

But this is the question that then needs to be answered.

If given a freedom to chart a new course, steering away from the conservative moorings of the clerics, and able to lean back on his earlier leftist philosophy from his youth, will he opt for a political solution with the clerics, or a principled stand in defiance of them?

Mousavi may never get a chance to show his leadership if the the Grand Ayatollah clamps down and murders in large enough numbers to end the protests.  But if he does get a chance at leadership let us hope Mousavi finds what Harry Truman did.  Something inside that moves the pages of history along.

The 20 Most Influential People In Iran…Who Will Play To History In Iran?

I suspect a large percentage of the world is closely following the events in Iran, reading and watching and wondering what will unfold in the hours and days to come.  Knowing Iran is rich in history, we are reminded that their grand past was also at times bloody.  The current events are a continuation of what we already know about this place, and culture.  But who will best determine the fate of those now protesting in the streets?  Where does the struggle go, and who will wield power, and in what fashion?  Who will play to history in Iran?

Here is a short list of the top 20 power brokers in Iran, and the role they play at this time.  The list was compiled and written shortly before the most recent Iranian election.

1. Ayatollah Ali Khamenei – Supreme Leader
Watch his actions, not his words. Having made his name as a pragmatist before taking over as Iran’s top holy man, he tries to reconcile the two roles: he tends to take the more popular side in every debate, while spouting radical rhetoric.

2. Mahmoud Ahmadinejad – President
Favored to win another four-year term as Iran’s second-most-powerful man. The Supreme Leader can always overrule him but until recently has tried to avoid direct confrontation. Khamenei is said to have particularly enjoyed his performance during nuclear negotiations.

3. Ayatollah Ali Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani– Eminence Grise
As head of the Expediency Council the ex-president is in charge of settling disputes between Iran’s Parliament and the Council of Guardians. A Khomeini confidant, he knows all the skeletons in the regime’s closet and may play a quiet role in U.S.-Iran talks.

4. Mohammad Khatami – Ex-President
After 18 years of conservative rule, Iranians were stunned by the reformist’s 1997 upset victory: their votes counted! Although he proved unable to keep his lofty promises, many young people still see him as the best hope for change. They took it hard when he quit this year’s race.

5. Ayatollah Ahmad Jannati – Oversight Chief
The Council of Guardians of the Islamic Revolution is a panel of six clerics and six lawyers that oversees all legislative bills and decides who can run in parliamentary and presidential elections. Its 83-year-old chief is an enthusiastic Ahmadinejad supporter.

. Ali Larijani – Majlis Speaker
The national legislature’s pragmatic leader is the well-heeled son of an influential cleric, as well as Iran’s former nuclear negotiator. He remains close to Khamenei. Ahmadinejad defeated Larijani in the 2005 presidential race, and their disputes since then have become a public spectacle.

7. Gen. Mohammad Ali Jafari – Revolutionary Guards Commander
Specialized in guerrilla missions and unconventional warfare during the war with Iraq. He’s said to owe his current post to his popularity with young troops and his up-to-date plans for defense against possible threats from Israel and America.

8. Mohammad Baqer Qalibaf – Mayor of Tehran
A former Revolutionary Guards commander and security chief, he stepped into Ahmadinejad’s old job as mayor after a failed bid for the presidency in 2005. Supporters praise him for fixing the mess they say Ahmadinejad left behind, and they hope he’ll do the same for Iran in 2013.

9. Ayatollah Abbas Vaez-Tabasi – Holy Estate Director
Controls what is arguably the country’s wealthiest single institution, the Holy Estate of Imam Reza, which owns hundreds of companies, mines and farms. Every year millions of pilgrims visit the shrine of the Shia saint, the only one buried in Iran.

10. Ayatollah Mohammad Taghi Mesbah Yazdi – Radical Scholar
The plugged-in director of the Imam Khomeini Education & Research Institute is one of the most hardline and influential interpreters of Islamic teachings in Qum. His students are among the city’s brightest and most politicized.

11. Seyyed Javad Shahrestani– Sistani’s Envoy
Despite 30 years of political Islam in Iran, many Shiites still see Iraq-based Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani as their religious leader, or marja (“object of emulation”). The resolutely apolitical Shahrestani is Sistani’s son-in-law, as well as his representative in the Islamic Republic.

12. Saeed Mortazavi – Prosecutor General of Tehran
Has been responsible for closing dozens of newspapers and sentencing journalists and activists to lengthy jail terms. Human-rights groups accuse him of harsh interrogation methods. He recently organized a group of lawyers to prosecute alleged Israeli crimes in Gaza.

13. Ayatollah Mahmoud Hashemi Shahroudi – Head of Judiciary
Born in Iraq, he was a leader in the fight against Saddam’s dictatorship before fleeing the country in 1979. Has made impressive progress on court reform since Khamenei named him top judge in 1999, but many judges remain beyond his jurisdiction.

14. Mojtaba Samareh Hashemi – Campaign Manager
Friends with Ahmadinejad since childhood, and an architect of his political rise, Samareh has been called an Iranian Karl Rove. He recently resigned from his post as a senior presidential adviser in order to devote himself full time to Ahmadinejad’s bid for reelection.

15. Mir Hossein Mousavi – Ex–Prime Minister
Dark-horse presidential candidate and an enigma to just about everyone. Older Iranians remember him as prime minister and a close Khomeini ally in the 1980s, but he’s spent the past 20 years painting and designing buildings. Now he’s wooing young voters as a reformist.

16. Mohsen Rezaei – Khamenei Adviser
The former Revolutionary Guards commander and secretary of the Expediency Council is a close and loyal adviser to the Supreme Leader. He’s a devout traditionalist but more pragmatic than the current president, and is hoping to unseat him in the June 12 elections.

17. Hossein Shariatmadari – Newspaper Editor
Khamenei’s top man at Kayhan, the leading conservative daily. His editorials, special reports and “Hidden Half” feature (devoted to the darker side of public figures he dislikes) read like a cross between intelligence reports and an Iranian version of Fox News.

18. BBC Persian Service – Illegal TV Network
The ban on satellite dishes is widely ignored: Iranians want news they can trust, not state TV. The Persian Voice of America is too pro-Washington for some. Since early this year, many have turned instead to the BBC and popular anchors like Farnaz Ghazizadeh (above).

19. Adel Ferdosipour – Sportscaster
Easily the country’s most popular TV host. When angry sports officials tried to get him fired recently for criticizing them on his weekly show (Iranian soccer, a national passion, is in crisis, beset by scandal and poor play), more than 3 million loyal fans sent text messages to keep him on.

20. Mehran Modiri – Social Satirist
Has survived 20 years by choosing his battles. Today his television comedies rule Iran’s airwaves, with audiences so big that broadcast executives don’t balk at his lampoons of Iranian life. Reformist politicians crave his endorsement, but he wants to stay in business.

Shame On Iran For Expelling BBC Reporter

Reuters/Tehran: “Iran has decided to expel the BBC’s correspondent in Tehran over the broadcaster’s coverage of this month’s election, an Iranian official said on Sunday, and a semi-official news agency said Jon Leyne had 24 hours to leave.

Without the reporters, cameras, and the eyes of history noting the events that transpire it only encourages rouge leaders and nations to try and act with impunity.  It is vital that those on Facebook, Twitter, and other social network sites stay active, and continuously convey the carnage and mayhem from the streets of Iran.

What is happening in Iran is very dismaying to witness.  The spirit yearns to be free of the bonds of the regime that has stolen an election.  The only way the elements who want to control Iran can win is if they completely break the ties of information flowing out to the rest of the world.

We must not let that happen.  The United States needs to do all that is required with satellite technology to see that the news from Iran is not allowed to be blocked, or under-reported.

Bob Woodward Does Not Vote For President

As a Richard Nixon buff I read all sorts of stuff about the former President, and the times in which he lived.  As such I ran across this nugget about one of the famed newspaper reporters of the last half of the 20th century.  Bob Woodward was essential to the story of Watergate, along with Carl Bernstein as they nosed their way to the story, and then reported it in the Washington Post.

I am however rather stunned to read that Bob Woodward has not cast a ballot for President since 1968!  I guess, though he does not address why, that it is so he can be more objective for his reporting on leaders from both sides of the aisle.    And yet….I do not think it necessary for objectivity to neuter ones responsibility at the polls.

But the biggest head-scratching moment comes when we learn that Woodward, despite all his moralizing about the reporter’s civic duty to expose the hidden workings of government, has not chosen to vote in a presidential election in over 40 years. And, the last time he entered the booth for that purpose, in 1968, he pulled the lever – for Richard Nixon.