Skip to content

Wisconsin Legislature Needs This New Year’s Resolution

January 2, 2016

Over the holidays I ran into one of the most colorful and conversant former members of the state assembly.  Without doubt Marlin Schneider carries more institutional memory of the statehouse than perhaps all the current members combined.    Agree with his politics or not, Schneider is a funny and insightful man.  As he was about to exit a restaurant we shook hands and talked a few minutes as the rest of his family gathered themselves so to leave too.

He mentioned a desire to have been in the fray over ACT 10, but sadly was not reelected to what would have been his last term.  It was obvious he misses the policy battles under the dome but it was clear the mean rhetoric of the current political climate was not something he wanted to be engaged in.    We mentioned how communities have been split, while family and friends are still deeply divided over all sorts of political issues that have developed since the election of Governor Walker in 2010.   I wanted to get his thoughts on how the political divide might be bridged but it was time to let him move on.

But I am sure he would have answered in the same way that so many would in this state to that very question.  No one knows how to stem the current tide of political chaos.

There is a meanness and crass nature to so much of our politics.  Not all of it takes places at the nati0nal level where not a day goes by without Donald Trump saying something that creates a new low in our political culture.  (I am quite certain Walker Cronkite would not have elevated much of what Trump said to the level of ‘news’ for his broadcasts.  The media certainly have a duty to play a more constructive role in our political discourse, too.)

At the state level there is the relentless politically planned attacks on state employees and public workers that started out as a strategy so to place Walker in the national spotlight.  Working feverishly to deny voters the accessibility to casting a ballot or attempting to limit women their health care rights are all part of an elbows out manner of governing in this state that has worked to turn citizen against citizen.  Perhaps most shameful of all was the attempt to portray refugees from war-torn Syria as something other than humans in need of help.

This is not to say our politics both locally and nationally have not always been frothy.  But in the recent past there is no denying of almost an effort to reach down for the lowest rung on the ladder with the desire to make that the new norm for the way we conduct politics.

Over the holidays while I was on a blogging break while either making cookies or eating them The Wisconsin State Journal published an article about former legislator and current lobbyist Gary Goyke.    His words are clear, to the point, and very accurate about the current breakdown in the way the government under the statehouse dome functions.

Yes. I believe that the current political polarization is almost all purposefully designed. People can choose how they will act in political matters. You can choose to be nice or nasty about individuals or policy. Being nasty is in vogue and advocated by many political managers. Nasty successfully divides people. Advice of campaign consultants who proscribe this philosophy may get a candidate to 51 percent, but they will never get a candidate into a history book for achieving any sense of what I believe should always be the main goal of government, which is seeking the Common Good.

The renowned Wisconsin legislative process is being greatly hampered by the current polarization. Many times standing committee members are purposely excluded from legislative matters until the very last minute. That would have been a rare occurrence years ago.

Developing a strategy to deliberately keep a minority out of the process is not respectful to any other colleague who represents the very same number of voters. That kind of behavior does not help build consensus in any way.

Legislative consensus has always built a stronger state of Wisconsin. In my opinion, some kind of consensus building process needs to return—and quickly.

But how does one right the ship of government when it is upside down in the water?  I have an idea.

Perhaps it is time to turn to the former leaders of this state–in a bi-partisan fashion–and have them brainstorm about what might be done to again fashion a working center for state politics so to make good, as Goyke stated, for “the Common Good”.  Bring former Assembly Speakers Tom Loftus and John Gard, former governors Tommy Thompson and Tony Earl, and former state senators Dale Schultz and Tim Cullen along with others together to put forth a blueprint on how collegiality can again lead us in our politics.  Get the editors of our state papers engaged in writing articles and OP-ED pieces so to then enlist the voters of the state to step up and also demand changes.

Our history shows what can happen when partisans place the common good ahead of everything else.  When Europe was starving after WWII it was Democratic President Harry Truman who turned to former Republican President Herbert Hoover to enlist his aid in formulating a plan to combat the human devastation in large parts of the world.  History shows us the rest of that successful  story.

The needs we have in Wisconsin are far less dire than that faced by Truman but the larger lesson should not be missed.  Working as colleagues in a fair and open-oriented process of governing will produce good policy, renew the electorate’s faith in government along with those elected to serve, and shine a light on Wisconsin as an example of how the values and ideals we share are still alive.

3 Comments leave one →
  1. January 2, 2016 11:58 PM

    I love your idea, but you’re forgetting one thing.

    Scott Walker isn’t listening to mere citizens like you or me. He could care less what might best benefit his constituents. Got a million bucks for He might listen to you then.

  2. January 2, 2016 3:07 PM

    If memory serves me the issue regarding John Gard had to do with how he made his requests for per diem. Representative Lary Swoboda (D) who I worked with had a bill for 2/3rds funding and had he been more able to be more than a back bencher could have better sold the idea. The 2/3rds idea was a good one–partisanship aside. Welfare reform was something I know about given some fights that took place within the code writing as Lary was Co-Chair of JCRAR. But having said all that there was also a whole different tone to everything vs how it is now. Thompson, several months after his first election, stopped by our office–we were ground floor next to an exit–and I was stunned to see him pop in to say hello to staff and step into Lary’s office for a quick chat. Staffers all hung together after work regardless of party for a beer and some throwing of darts. The current level of bombast and rancor and how that then undermines governing needs to be turned around. The important question seems to be not how it started but how best to stop it.

  3. January 2, 2016 2:46 PM

    The Capital Times bought and paid for much of the enmity in today’s politics. It and the Democratic wing of the Democratic party vilified Tommy Thompson, ridiculed his speech patterns, called him “King Tommy” and fought welfare reform with vituperation. When he guaranteed 2/3rds state funding for public school districts, they damned the resultant increase in state spending. John Gard? The Capital Times went ballistic over the fact that he had a second home in Sun Prairie so he could spend more time with his family rather than driving every night to their home in Peshtigo, which is closer to Lake Superior than to Madison.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: