When New York Jets quarterback Aaron Rodgers was removed from the first game of the 2023 football season due to an injury and then unable to play anymore, I felt the bizarre and quirky conspiracy theories he willingly percolates might fade. We know they did not, and among a subset of Americans, his downright fact-less views only make him more appealing. It is so true when saying we should never underestimate the stupidity of the American public.
Over the past week, independent presidential candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has ginned up a way to get press coverage by stating Rodgers was on a list for the vice-presidential slot. Rodgers will not give up his NFL paycheck to become an even greater national punchline. Kennedy has proven he will do almost anything, including this quixotic leap of name-dropping, to be relevant. But just as the press had used up a news cycle on an impossible VP story came the bombshell that in private conversations Rodgers came down on the side of a bat-crap-crazy conspiracy theory that the abhorrent 2012 Sandy Hook school shooting was not real.
CNN reported how one journalist, Pamela Brown, had a personal conversation with the then-Green Bay Packers player.
Brown was covering the Kentucky Derby for CNN in 2013 when she was introduced to Rodgers, then with the Green Bay Packers, at a post-Derby party. Hearing that she was a journalist with CNN, Rodgers immediately began attacking the news media for covering up important stories. Rodgers brought up the tragic killing of 20 children and 6 adults by a gunman at Sandy Hook Elementary School, claiming it was actually a government inside job and the media was intentionally ignoring it.
When Brown questioned him on the evidence to show this very real shooting was staged, Rodgers began sharing various theories that have been disproven numerous times. Brown recalls Rodgers asking her if she thought it was odd that there were men in black in the woods by the school, falsely claiming those men were actually government operatives. Brown found the encounter disturbing.
CNN has spoken to another person with a similar story. This person, to whom CNN has granted anonymity so as to avoid harassment, recalled that several years ago, Rodgers claimed, “Sandy Hook never happened…All those children never existed. They were all actors.”
When asked about the grieving parents, the source recalled Rodgers saying, “They’re all making it up. They’re all actors.”
Rodgers went on to delve into some of the darker caverns of the false conspiracy theory. This person found the encounter disturbing.
Disturbing is not even the tip of the iceberg when seeking words about how I would describe my feelings about Rodgers. What allowed him to fall so far away from the role model many felt worthy for their children will be written about in the years ahead. Some will question his football profession and possible brain injuries as to the cause of his behavior, while others, without a doubt, will just question his flawed character as a man. What is without question, however, is the trajectory of his career. It is safe to view it on the same arc as the man everybody once called ‘America’s Mayor’.
I recall the years when placing mobsters and mafia leaders in prison was what made Giuliani famous. And for good reason. The majority of the nation best recalls Giuliani’s leadership after the September 11 attacks in 2001, the year he also was named Time magazine’s Person of the Year. Those were the years when Guiliani had his compass aligned due North, as he played a very positive role in the nation. Likewise, Rodgers, but in a very separate and far less important slice of the national fabric, fulfilled his role as someone who could be viewed with a positive connotation on the football field. I have never been able to pinpoint when Giuliani’s personal life or his hubris with a consulting business pulled him off the track, but all know what Rudy became over the past decade. He is a continuous national joke for late-night television along with being scorned and reviled across our land.
There is no question, however, when the nation became aware that Rodgers had run afoul of logic and reason. The COVID-19 pandemic showcased his refusal to be fact-based about science, vaccinations, or understand the gravity of the virus that was killing far too many in Wisconsin. This week, we discovered the shocking news about his disgusting views regarding one of the most horrific mass school shootings in our country. His bizarre and tasteless rants about his conspiracy-laden views are becoming the narrative about the man. Everyone with a pulse knows that 9/11 and Sandy Hook actually happened. What perverse pleasure Rodgers gets from further wounding the parents and families of Sandy Hook shows what a broken and truly pathetic character looks like. All we need to see is the brown liquid running down Rodger’s face. Then the Giuliani connection will have come full circle.